Who's who: Macdonald Smith

  • Nairn GC.jpg
  • Prince's GC, England
  • Peterhead GC
  • 30bb297e-e7f4-4990-93c9-b8c1e64fdd82.JPG
  • Littlestone GC
  • Brora GC
  • Cabot Highlands - Castel Stuart course
  • Torrey Pines - South Course 1

Who's who: Macdonald Smith

  • Name:

    Macdonald "Mac" Smith
  • Country:

    Scotland
  • Lived:

    [1890-1949]. Born on March 18, 1890 in Carnoustie, Angus, Scotland. Died on Aug 31, 1949 in Glendale, Los Angeles County, California.
  • Original/Home Club:

    Carnoustie, Scotland.
  • Occupation:

    Professional golfer and club pro.
  • Turned Pro:

    1908

Roll of Honour

Total professional wins (29), including PGA Tour wins (25).

Did you know?

"Mac" Smith (b.1890) and his five older brothers (Alex, Willie, John, George and Jim), were part of a large golfing family from Barry, a small village next to Carnoustie. Mac, and his brothers Alex (b.1874) and Willie (b.1876) all migrated to the USA as young men, eager to pursue the more lucrative golfing opportunities that lay "across the pond".

Although "Mac" missed out on major championship honours (he is widely regarded as one of the best players of all time not to have won a major), he eventually recorded many more American professional circuit wins than his brothers. In 1930 he came second in both the Open Championship and the US Open (on both occasions runner-up to Bobby Jones). The latter title had already been won "within the family", in 1899 by his brother Willie, and by Alex in 1906 and 1910.

Top tournaments won by Macdonald Smith

1936
America
Inglewood GC, WA
285 (-7)
$1,200
x

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Inglewood GC, WA

Score

285 (-7)

Prize money

$1,200

Title sponsor

x

Played as the inaugural Seattle Open (Jul 31-Aug 3; next played in 1945). 46-year-old Macdonald Smith (Scot/USA) beat Ralph Guldahl (USA) in an 18-hole Monday playoff (Smith 8-under 65, Guldahl 71), to record the last of his 25 PGA Tour wins. [Inglewood GC, Kenmore, nr Seattle, WA].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

280 (E)

Prize money

$1,450

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Los Angeles Open (Jan 5-8). Second-placed Willie Hunter (Scot/USA) and Bill Mehlhorn (USA) finished 8 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA), who claimed this title for the fourth time in seven years. Second-place was only decided on the following day (Tuesday), after darkness prevented the contenders, Willie Hunter and George Von Elm, completing the last two holes of their final rounds. [Los Angeles CC, Los Angeles, CA].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

282 (E)

Prize money

$500

Title sponsor

WGA

Played as the Western Open (Aug 25-27). Second-placed Tommy Armour (Scot/USA) finished 6 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [No.4 (North) course (par-70), Olympia Fields CC, nr Chicago, IL. One of the first two rounds for each player on the par-72 No.1 (South) course].

1932
America
Hillcrest CC, CA
281 (-3)
$2,000
x

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Hillcrest CC, CA

Score

281 (-3)

Prize money

$2,000

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Los Angeles Open (Jan 8-11). Second-placed Leo Diegel (USA), Olin Dutra (USA), Joe Kirkwood Sr (Aus) and Dick Metz (USA) finished 4 shots behind Madonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Hillcrest CC, Los Angeles, CA].

1931
America
Crestmont CC, NJ
285 (-3)
Metropolitan GA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Crestmont CC, NJ

Score

285 (-3)

Prize money

Title sponsor

Metropolitan GA

Played as the Metropolitan Open (July 16-18). Second-placed Gene Sarazen (USA) finished 5 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Crestmont CC, West Orange, New Jersey].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

285 (+1)

Prize money

$3,500

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Los Angeles Open (Jan 11-14). Second-placed Tommy Armour (Scot/USA) finished 6 shots behind defending champion Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). The leaders finished on Monday (14th), but darkness required some players to finish the following day. [Riviera CC, Pacific Palisades, Los Angeles, CA].

1928
America
Wilshire CC
284 (E)
$3,500
x

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Wilshire CC

Score

284 (E)

Prize money

$3,500

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Los Angeles Open (Jan 5-8). Second-placed Harry "Lighthorse" Cooper (USA) finished 3 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Wilshire CC, Central Los Angeles, CA].

1926
America
Evanston GC
277 (-3)
$1,000
Chicago District GA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Evanston GC

Score

277 (-3)

Prize money

$1,000

Title sponsor

Chicago District GA

Played as the Chicago District Open (Aug 31/Sep 1). Second-placed Eddie Loos (USA) finished 1 shot behind Macdonald Smith (Scot/USA). [Evanston GC, Skokie, Illinois].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

288 (+4)

Prize money

$1,500

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Texas Open (Jan 15-17). Second-placed Bobby Cruickshank (Scot) finished 1 shot behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA), the runner-up in this event the previous year. [Brackenridge Park GC, San Antonio, TX].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

283 (-9)

Prize money

$500

Title sponsor

x

Played as the Canadian Open (Aug 5-7). Second-placed Gene Sarazen (USA) finished 3 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Royal Montreal GC, Dixie, Dorval, Montreal - this course no longer exists].

1926
America
Salisbury GC
286 (-6)
$500
Metropolitan GA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Salisbury GC

Score

286 (-6)

Prize money

$500

Title sponsor

Metropolitan GA

Played as the Metropolitan Open (July 15-18, 24). Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA) beat defending champion Gene Sarazen (USA) after a marathon playoff that lasted 54 holes. In their 18-hole Sunday morning playoff both had 3-under-par 70s; this necessitated a further 18-hole playoff in the afternoon, which they tied 72 apiece. The following Saturday, Smith prevailed in the third 18-hole playoff (Smith 66, Sarazen 70). Over the course of the championship (which lasted for seven rounds over ten days) Smith ran up a total score of 494, to Sarazen's 498. [No.3 course, Salisbury GC, Westbury, Long Island, NY. Although Salisbury GC no longer exists, the Championship course is largely preserved as the Red course, Eisenhower Park GC].

1925
America
Youngstown CC
281 (-3)
$500
WGA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Youngstown CC

Score

281 (-3)

Prize money

$500

Title sponsor

WGA

Played as the Western Open (25th) (Aug 20-22). Second-placed Leo Diegel (USA), Johnny Farrell (USA), Emmet French (USA), Walter Hagen (USA) and defending champion Bill Mehlhorn (USA) finished 6 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Youngstown CC, Youngstown, Ohio].

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Score

281 (-7)

Prize money

$500

Title sponsor

x

Played as the North & South Open (April 1/2). Second-placed and defending champion Walter Hagen (USA) finished 8 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [No.2 Course, Pinehurst Resort, North Carolina].

1914
America
Scarsdale GC
278
$150
Metropolitan GA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Scarsdale GC

Score

278

Prize money

$150

Title sponsor

Metropolitan GA

Played as the Metropolitan Open (Aug 27/28). Second-placed Willie Macfarlane (Scot) finished 9 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). At the time, Smith's 278 was the lowest 72-hole score ever recorded in a "major" championship, matching Arthur Smith's 278 in the 1905 Western Open. [Scarsdale GC, Hartsdale, NY].

1912
America
Idlewild CC
299 (+11)
$300
WGA

Category

America

Winner (holder)

Smith, Macdonald

Venue

Idlewild CC

Score

299 (+11)

Prize money

$300

Title sponsor

WGA

Played as the Western Open (Aug 28/29; reverted to stroke play after two years as a match play event). Second-placed Alec Robertson (Scot/USA) finished 4 shots behind Macdonald "Mac" Smith (Scot/USA). [Idlewild CC, Flossmoor, nr Chicago, IL].

Find a course

Or

Tournaments

124th US Open: the No.2 Course at Pinehurst once again plays host to this most illustrious championship (June 13-16). Wyndham Clark defends his title, having won at Los Angeles CC in 2023.

79th Women’s US Open: the second women’s major championship of the season gets underway at Lancaster CC in Pennsylvania. It’s the second time the championship has been held here.
(May 30-June 2).

Who's Who

Nelly Korda: won the Mizuho Americas Open (May 16-19) at Liberty National GC, continuing her extraordinary form in LPGA events. This was her sixth win in seven starts in 2024.

Xander Schauffele: recorded his first major championship win, and second record-equalling low score of 62 in a major. Only he, Branden Grace, Rickie Fowler and Shane Lowry have achieved this feat in a men’s major championship.

Marco Simone Golf & Country Club

Marco Simone Golf & Country Club: With a clubhouse that might befit a Roman Emperor, and a golf course to match, you can be sure of a memorable outing at Rome's most talked about golf facility.

Jim Fazio's original layout was much changed to create a modern Ryder Cup course ... now one of the Eternal City's (and Italy's) most revered.

Prince's Golf Club, Kent (UK)

Here at Prince’s Golf Club you'll find 27 excellent holes of links golf. Just over the fence and sharing similar terrain is Royal St George’s; but Prince’s is far from overshadowed by its venerable neighbour. The three nine-hole loops at Prince's, laid out over gently undulating terrain, are sure to bring a smile of satisfaction to all lovers of links golf.

Stay&Play at Prince's: excellent onsite Lodge accommodation available

Popular videos

You can subscribe to the Where2Golf channel on YT if you like to see more video content. You'll find a "Subscribe" button on any of our YouTube videos. Or if you want a quick and direct access subscribe here. Once done, any new published videos will show up in your Subscriptions feed.

Whistling Straits (Wisconsin, US)

Hamburger GC - Falkenstein, Germany

Littlestone Golf Club (Kent, UK)